Skip to Content

How to Restore Worn Leather Shoes – So Good!

I love decorating with old English riding boots and English saddles, but often the condition I find these items in is far from pristine. While I enjoy weathered antiques, when it comes to leather, it’s not a great look. Often, just a little conditioner and dye make the difference between an item that belongs in the trash and an item that complements a sophisticated equestrian-inspired look.

Whether you are restoring an antique for display or refreshing a beloved pair of boots for another season of styling with your favorite outfits, this step-by-step method for restoring the appearance of worn leather is easily worth the time investment for dramatic results. Some TLC will get your worn leather shoes looking great and help them to last longer.

Below is a great example of the transformation of a pair of riding boots from “ugh” to fab! I stumbled across these boots at a thrift store. Commonly with cheap riding boots, friction between the rider’s leg and the saddle discolors or even removes the dye from the inside of the boot. To restore these boots to display-condition, the boots needed black dye added to the discolored surfaces.

Worn leather patches on black riding boots
Riding boots before

Refreshed and redyed leather boots
The same riding boots after

First, Clean Your Boots!

Start by cleaning your leather item.

It may be tempting to just wipe the item down, but leather goods like boots and saddles will have a tough gummy substance on the surface (a combination of dirt merging with the oils present in leather). Scrubbing with soap and water is necessary to remove this residue. Use as little water as possible, but do clean thoroughly. Don’t worry, oiling later will restore any oils lost during cleaning.

The following section may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Prepare to Apply Dye to the Leather

Once completely dry, it’s time to dye your worn boots.

A local leather shop can help you match shades of brown if you are dying a delicate item, but an easier option, if you are working with a light colored item, is to dye the entire surface a darker shade.

When working with black items such as riding boots, Fiebings Black Leather Dye is always a safe bet- I’ve done perhaps a half dozen black boots and saddles with no color matching issues, using this inexpensive but professional-grade dye.

Black boots on a table.

Using dye can be messy! Prepare and be careful- protect your skin and surrounding surfaces from this permanent dye!

Prepare your area

Listen, no matter how careful you are, you WILL permanently stain whatever surface you work on. So plan ahead!

  • I recommend working on top of a flattened cardboard box with a trashbag or plastic drop cloth underneath it. The cardboard forms a very absorbant layer, preventing drips and splashes.
  • Wear clothes you’d paint in.
  • Use thin exam gloves or, in a pinch, thick rubber gloves (the latter makes fine movement harder, so I prefer thin exam or food prep gloves)

In these photos, I’m working on a cardboard sheet placed on top of a masonite sheet.

Worn leather boots on top of a protected surface, with supplies to restore them in the foreground.

Prepare your tools:

You’ll need dish gloves or latex gloves and something to transfer dye with.

Sometimes dye comes with a dab of wool, but you may need something larger. Here, I use a chunk of wool roving.

Restoring a worn boot using dye and a bit of wool roving.

Apply Dye to Restore the Worn Leather to New Looking:

Working quickly but carefully, paint the dye onto the surface of the leather.

The dye may sit for a few minutes on the surface of the leather appearing to pool up on the surface- but that’s ok! You’ll notice this effect particularly in spots where the original finish is intact.

Let the dye sit on the surface for a few minutes, giving it a chance to soak in.

leather dye soaking in to worn patches on an old black riding boot

Most dye will absorb immediately. Let the boot sit for 2-3 minutes and wipe off the excess dye with a clean, soft cloth.

You may need to buff with a bit of elbow grease to restore a nice finish.

You’ll see lots of improvement after one coat, but some thick full grain leather items like saddles usually need a second or even third coat to penetrate the leather fully.

A hand wipes off excess dye from a boot.
The majority of the dye will absorb into the leather almost instantly.

Allow the dye to fully dry, apply your favoirte shoe polish or leather conditioner, buff the sruface, and enjoy your newly restored leather!

Worn leather riding boots looking new with an application of dye.

Fiebings dye is alcohol based, and will dry quickly. Once completely dry you can put the item to use immediately! You may wish to oil or condition the item to prolong life and restore the oils lost during the cleaning step.

Still need some work on your boots? For restoring plush, fleece, or sheepskin boot liners, check out my tutorial, if your boots are a little too big and giving you blisters, try the same trick I use to keep heels from slipping, it works great on boots too!

owl, bucket, riding boots on porch

Restore Leather Shoes can look great with some love and a little TLC

Black boots next to a pumpkin on a porch.

TIP: Getting Riding Boots to Stand Straight for Display.

Traditionally, riding boots were stored with wooden boot trees, which look beautiful but are difficult to find (and very expensive!) now. There are many functional plastic options for storing “working” riding boots, but for display, it’s difficult to find an option that looks vintage and supports the boot properly.

To hold the boots upright that I use for display, I now cut and place a 2×2 inside the boot. Screwed once through the sole, and once to the back of the calf, boots with a board secured as illustrated will not sag or tilt, and still have room to be used as a vase for flower bouquets or farm christmas decoration greenery as the seasons change.

A photo of boots showing where they are braced.

Thanks for Reading!!!

I hope you can tell that I love DIY, researching the best affordable solutions for every-day problems opportunities and documenting / sharing solutions!🙌 is reader-supported.

☕ is reader-supported. If this article saved you time or money, please consider donating $1 to help me cover the cost of hosting this website OR If you appreciate this information and want to throw a “Thanks!” my way by buying me a coffee – I would Of Course appreciate it! :]

Reader Questions and Recommendations

Readers, do you have any favorite topics / posts? What would you like to read more about in the future? As I hope you can tell from this and other articles on my site, I really enjoy DIY / a good challenge, and I’m not afraid to roll up my sleeves to figure out a great, and hopefully simple 😁 solution. So please feel free to let me know in the comments below (or reach out via social media)!

Ok Really – I’ll try to wrap this up now😂

Finally, if you’d like to continue to learn about interesting DIY options as well as how YOU can tackle creative new projects consider checking out the latest and most popular articles listed on the Hawk-Hill Home Page. I’m always trying to enjoy and write about the creative side of life so please don’t be a stranger – check back often!😍

If you enjoyed this post you may also enjoy reading / perusing / devouring😊 one or all of these articles as well!